I think the thing you might dislike is the Shipyard yeast / brew systems. I have not gone through all of your reviews to check, but that would be a simple guess. So many people use the system and yeast strain that Allan Puglsey has that, you will notice a flavor profile to beers that match it. Farmhouse T&G in Burlington doesn't serve Shipyard because several of the people there don't like that flavor profile.Also Sebago is contract brewed by Shipyard.
Hmmm...that might be it although there are some Shipyard beers that I've liked (their Prelude winter warmer and Imperial Porter) but yeah, that's good to know about their yeast/brew systems. I'll keep that in mind. Thanks!